Dan T.
8/31/2025
In from out of town and came to this location two mornings in a row. Kept it simple with cold brew and an English breakfast tea. Also had a ham and cheese croissant. Everything was really good....
Picky Barista
$
Closed
(51)
Photos
667 Columbus Ave
New York, NY 10025
Picky Barista is a family-owned coffee shop in New York City that offers a cozy and hip atmosphere with a European vibe. With a passion for coffee and over 10 years of experience in the hospitality industry, Picky Barista serves delicious drinks and homemade pastries, providing outstanding hospitality and a chill atmosphere.
They proudly serve Stumptown Coffee Roasters, known for their strong and creamy coffee sourced directly from producers around the world, while also prioritizing sustainability and fair treatment of their producers. Picky Barista's carefully selected espresso machine, the hand-assembled Slayer Steam, ensures that their espresso shots come out with the perfect amount of crema. With their adorably decorated space and colorful selection of coffee cups, Picky Barista is the go-to spot for coffee lovers looking for a delightful and satisfying experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.551 reviews
Peta W.
11/10/2025
Quick cafe to grab a bit, coffee, catch up or get some work done. Bit busy but workable. Service was quick, PSL was yummy and creamy! The place is airy and bright even on dreary fall days.
Taylor K.
11/1/2025
Yummy hot cocoa. fast for how busy they were. It was creamy, sugary and delicious. Only allow laptops on certain days so check website if planning to work from here.
Nazneen M.
11/10/2025
This is a popular and lively venue but also quiet enough to curl up with a book. The matcha was too mild for my taste. I liked hanging out here, regardless. It was good service.
Jenny H.
11/9/2024
I decided to find a local café to work and grab a cup of solid latte. Decided to visit Picky Barista because I like a takeout I had a couple of weekends before. Unfortunately on a Thursday...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.