Laura D.
9/30/2025
I finally decided to give this place a try since I live down the street. Not sure why other people gave strange reviews that have nothing to do with the bagels. I love that they have a choice for...
Pick A Bagel
$
Open
(178)
Photos
37 W End Ave
New York, NY 10023
Pick A Bagel has been crafting authentic New York bagels since 1988, utilizing traditional methods that include hand-rolling and kettle boiling each bagel to perfection. With nearly thirty years of experience, this establishment continues to uphold a legacy of quality by using only the finest ingredients and baking everything fresh in-house.
Located throughout Manhattan, Pick A Bagel invites customers to indulge in a true New York bagel experience. Their commitment to maintaining a delicious tradition ensures that every bagel is made with care and expertise, making it a beloved choice for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
2.5178 reviews
Cole D.
5/24/2025
No reason for hate at this place. Now Kossar's btw. I had one of the best bagels my 3 years here in the city. Egg everything with sun dried tomato cream cheese. Blew my mind. I was actually...
Sawako Y.
4/6/2024
I'd been to the Pick A Bagel on 8th Ave, but this was my first time at this UWS location. My friend is a regular here, so the staff knew her drink order, which was cool. We ordered 2 bagels to...
Bret B.
9/14/2024
I am a frequent visitor and love Pick A Bagel's Bagels and smears. Only reason it's not a five star is it is very expensive . Service is fast, but not so friendly. A few small tables and...
GarGuPi L.
3/23/2025
Now switched to Kossar but same staff and also bialy . Faster transaction and also improved menu
See a problem?
