Hope P.
5/4/2025
Great pizza , their "weird" sauce is really good. Always positive and friendly, definitely recommend trying a slice
Peter's New York Pizzeria
$
Closed
(21)
Photos
12013 E Main St
Wolcott, NY 14590
Peter's New York Pizzeria in Wolcott, NY, has been a family-owned and operated establishment since 1991, earning a reputation as the region's best pizzeria. Known for its homemade menu offerings, the pizzeria provides a warm neighborhood atmosphere where guests can enjoy fresh, hot meals served by dedicated hosts.
With a menu featuring a variety of pizzas, wings, and other fine foods, Peter's New York Pizzeria caters to both dine-in and take-out customers. Over the years, it has become a local favorite, renowned for its commitment to quality and authentic Italian cuisine.
Generated from the website
Reviews
5.021 reviewsChris C.
8/12/2025
We were camping at a nearby campground and decided to stop for pizza. We were the only people there but I have to say the food was excellent! I love Ricotta cheese on my pizza. Most places don't...
Mike B.
9/1/2023
Was driving through town recently and wanted a quick late afternoon snack. This place was exactly what I hoped it would be. The guy working the counter was friendly and welcoming. He still had a...
Brian G.
3/26/2022
Our tax guy is right around the corner from this pizza shop and my appointment ended right at lunchtime. I had two slices, a diet Dr Pepper and blue cheese. $11.25 for all. The slices had a...
Emma M.
7/22/2024
Food was delicious and prices were very reasonable. Got two slices of pizza, 4 garlic knots, and a drink and it came out to only $14! Garlic knots were very good, I even went back and got 5 more...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.