Eric K.
6/13/2025
This diner was amazing! Service was fast, food was great and affordable prices! It has the typically diner look but it's very clean and a great atmosphere!
Peter's Bay Village Diner
$
Open
(68)
Photos
236 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701
Bay Village Diner, situated in Amityville, NY, offers a convenient pick-up service for customers looking to enjoy their delicious meals at home. Located south of Sunrise Highway, under the railroad tracks on Broadway route 110, this diner provides a range of delectable options to satisfy any craving.
For those seeking the ultimate convenience, Bay Village Diner also offers delivery services through popular platforms like DoorDash and Uber Eats, ensuring that customers can enjoy their favorite dishes without leaving the comfort of their own homes.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.068 reviews
R W.
10/11/2025
I ordered chicken salad on a roll. Absolutely no flavor and soggy. It came with a nasty little piece of pickle.
Philip Z.
12/9/2024
I would be hard pressed to find something to complain about when reviewing this diner. Plenty of parking, then enter a nice warm place on a chilly morning. Greeted warmly by the owner and seated...
Joe C.
1/25/2025
The food,service and ambiance it's spot on,nice friendly people and great food. I'll surely go back.
Christine D.
12/1/2023
I have lived in Amityville for 25 years, a neighbor mentioned how good this dinner is, so we tried it. I'm not a dinner girl, but this dinner is like an old fashion dinner, everything is...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.