Bonnie B.
1/16/2022
We went here last night based on the reviews. In terms of food, which is truly the thing restaurants really should get right, they absolutely did! We didn't order any appetizers. Our server was...
Pennachio's
$$
Open
(103)
Photos
460 County Road 111
Manorville, NY 11949
History
After 27 years of living in Manorville with no exceptional place to find Italian cuisine, owner Tom Pennachio took the situation into his own hands and opened Pennachio's restaurant and pizzeria.
Specialties
Pennachio's employees pride themselves on customer service by providing a friendly, family-style environment to their customers. The pasta dishes are guaranteed to amaze loyal customers and newcomers, alike. Tremendous portions allow for the customer to enjoy the rest of the meal the next day. The pizzeria offers an array of specialty slices and the classics! We deliver to Manorville, Moriches, and Eastport for a $3.00 delivery fee- starting at 3:00 Monday & Tuesday and ALL DAY Wednesday-Sunday.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0103 reviews
Jeff G.
10/16/2025
I have no idea how this place has four stars on yelp! I walked in at 6 PM on a Wednesday after a long drive in traffic. There was not a person in the place and the pizza counter options looked...
Kevin C.
1/4/2025
Wow. Wife and I heading west and stopped for slices. I noticed a special listed in the window. $6.99 two slices and 24oz fountain soda. We order 4 slices, 2 small(12oz?) sodas. We were charged...
John A.
6/16/2025
It didn't look good but I was hungry. Tasteless and greasy regular slice. Stopped on my way home from south fork. One of the worst slices of pizza I've eaten.
Keith P.
12/17/2024
I just moved to Suffolk and was looking for an Italian spot to eat at last night which was a Monday. Most places were closed, but Pennachio's was open and had good reviews. My wife and I sat...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.