Carmelo V.
8/9/2025
Best pizza on the island. My wife has can't eat gluten and they had a gluten free pie and it was amazing. I can eat anything and I had 2 slices with sausage and it was hot and very flavorful....
Pelligrino's Pizza
Permanently closed
(50)
Photos
99 Route 25A
Shoreham, NY 11786
Pellegrino's Pizza, located in Shoreham, NY, offers a diverse menu featuring both traditional and specialty pizzas crafted with quality ingredients. Their selection includes Neapolitan, Sicilian, and unique creations like the Grandma Sicilian Pizza and Mike's Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza, ensuring there's something to satisfy every palate.
In addition to pizza, Pellegrino's serves a range of appetizers, salads, and family meal deals, making it a go-to spot for casual dining and takeout. With a focus on flavor and customer satisfaction, this establishment aims to deliver delightful dining experiences for families and friends alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.550 reviewsNathan W.
8/1/2025
We get Pelligrino's frequently. The pizza is consistently delicious, and nicely cooked. Their meatballs are excellent. The chicken tenders and fries are also enjoyable. The owner and their...
noreen f.
8/3/2025
Had food from this restaurant in the past and it was good. i ordered a meatball pizza and it was undercooked, bland and a couple of slices had no meatball and the rest had one thin square piece of...
Jon T.
8/25/2024
Been all over New York and eaten at a lot of pizza places. I found this gem recently and not only is the staff so friendly the pizza fantastic. Plus they didn't charge me crazy price for some...
Maria H.
7/1/2024
The people are nice. The sicilian pie was not crispy, and it was not for me. I felt like I was eating frozen pizza. Sorry, I would not order from them again.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.