Rich L.
9/5/2025
Went to Paulie's twice last week. Excellent thin cheese slices! My new go- to place in the area.
Paulie's Pizzeria
Closed
(22)
Photos
76 E Pulaski Rd
Huntington Station, NY 11746
Paulie's Pizzeria, located at 76 East Pulaski Road in Huntington Station, NY, is a local favorite known for its classic pizza offerings as well as unique specialty pies. In addition to pizza, the menu includes a variety of heros and pasta dishes to satisfy all cravings.
With a commitment to quality and flavor, Paulie's Pizzeria invites customers to order inside, ensuring a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. This pizzeria is dedicated to serving up delicious food that keeps patrons coming back for more.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.522 reviews
Bill S.
8/29/2025
This is the *BEST* pizza on Long Island for 2025 - Bill S There, I said it. The lines have been drawn. I read the article in Newsday saying the team's goal was "to create a circa-1979-era New...
Deanna K.
9/8/2025
Tried Paulie's for the first time today for lunch. It will be my final time. Growing up on Long Island and working in Manhattan, i've walked into my fair share of pizzerias. This time was...
George C.
10/16/2025
Been here a bunch. Love their pizza and their garlic knots are awesome. The only problem I see is that they now charge $9.00 for toppings on a pie. If you like two.... $18 bucks. This kinda price...
Andrea R.
9/18/2025
Excellent Spicy Stracciatella pizza!!! Ours had no pepperoni as we needed it vegetarian. I'm sure it's even better with it. I am a big fan of the taste of their sauce. It was so fresh. I will be...
See a problem?
