Sean U.
7/20/2025
From the moment you step into Pastitalia, you can tell this isn't just another pasta spot--it's a labor of love. Elena and Matteo, a talented Italian couple from Elba, have poured their passion...
Pastitalia
$
Closed
(35)
Photos
264 Lenox Ave
New York, NY 10027
Freshly homemade pasta every day to suit every taste: long, short and stuffed pastas, served ready to eat or in servings you can cook at home and dress with our fresh meat, fish and vegetarian sauces.
Find related places
Reviews
4.535 reviews
Ed M.
7/18/2025
Great hidden gem! Fresh pasta and salad ! Italian beer! Holds maybe 10 folks! Everything fresh and home made. Enjoy.
Wendy H.
7/5/2025
Nothing beats fresh pasta on a nice summer evening. Mix and match sauces with the many types of pasta they have available. Similar to their sister restaurant, Sottocasa, Pastitalia focuses on...
Lauren W.
11/23/2025
Supremely delicious fresh pasta and friendly people in a convenient spot not far from all the action on 125th St!
Kimberly L.
11/20/2025
Just ok. If you're in a pinch and need somewhere to eat, this place will do. Overpriced a bit for how basic it is and portion sizes are on the smaller side. Usually long-ish wait times for food....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.