Russ A.
3/18/2025
This is Long Island pizza; everything else is imitation. Best pizza, you have to order at least two pies because it is so good you finish it so fast you need another.
Pappalardo's Pizza Cove
$
Closed
(86)
Photos
1079 Hicksville Rd
Seaford, NY 11783
Pappalardo's Pizza Cove in Seaford, NY has been recognized by Long Island's Newsday newspaper for serving the best pizza on Long Island. Their staff is known for making fresh dough daily, contributing to their exceptional quality.
With a diverse menu featuring a variety of delicious pizza, pasta, and Italian dishes, Pappalardo's offers a satisfying dining experience for all Italian cuisine enthusiasts in the area.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
3.586 reviews
Michael L.
6/23/2024
This local legend is the only pizza cove in New York!! PAPPALARDO's has great weekly & family specials that are among some of the best pizza deals around! The service is always great providing...
Hit Man D.
12/7/2024
Love me some Cove pie! I'm headed home for Xmas and plan on grabbing Johnny Mel and headed in one afternoon for some grub. Keep those ovens hot, gang!
Melanie D.
6/11/2023
You can feel the family energy in here, sweet young folks working at the front have a decent variety of pizza. The slices are on the heavier side when it comes to the dough so if that's your pizza...
Bryan B.
4/14/2025
Been coming here for years. Joey and his crew are usually spot on. Food is always good. But the last few times, the staff at night at least (kids) are subpar to say the least. The other night, the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.