Handsome R.
4/28/2025
Excellent pizza, so glad I stumbled on this place, pizza was fantastic and everyone behind the counter was extremely pleasant. As soon as you walk in the place is super clean smells great and very...
Papa’s Pizza
Open
(9)
Photos
199 Merritts Rd
Farmingdale, NY 11735
Papa’s Pizza is a popular pizzeria in Farmingdale, NY, known for serving a variety of classic and specialty pizzas.
With a focus on quality ingredients and friendly service, Papa’s Pizza offers a casual dining experience for customers looking to enjoy delicious pizza in a cozy atmosphere.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.09 reviewsMary S.
8/23/2025
Great pizza. The crust is perfect. Classic Sicilian. Ate it too fast. This pepperoni is delicious!!!! sleeper pizza place!
Gregg T.
12/3/2023
It's been two very long days since we reviewed Papa's and just had to go back. I have never heard of Brooklyn Pizza which blows my mind being an X NYer and A Pizza Chef Hobbyist. Picked one up...
Denny J.
4/5/2024
Stopped in to this pizza shop which is nestled in a small shopping strip with plenty of parking. The staff were friendly and happy. The shop is a bit small with some tables on the side and the...
Sheldon L.
10/13/2024
I visited papas pizza a few months ago when I was visiting my parents in New York and man this place was so good. So this week my parents were visiting me in Texas and I asked them to bring some...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.