Mike P.
5/16/2025
Awhile back, I left a pretty bad review for this place. Since then, they've changed owners, and made some much needed cosmetic changes to the storefront as well (not that it matters that much,...
Papa Nick's Pizza
Permanently closed
(71)
Photos
117 S Country Rd Ste C
Bellport, NY 11713
Papa Nick's Pizzeria in Bellport, NY is a beloved family-owned Italian pizzeria named after owner Sebastian Tauriello's father, Nick. With a rich heritage of authentic Italian recipes passed down through generations, the Tauriello family takes pride in offering quality dishes made with fresh ingredients and traditional techniques.
Customers rave about the delicious and flavorful pizzas, generous portions, and friendly staff at Papa Nick's. From classic pies to specialty pizzas and homemade meatballs, this independent pizzeria continues to delight locals and visitors alike with its genuine taste of Italian-American cuisine.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.071 reviewsJoseph P.
10/9/2025
I've been here a few times because it has been convenient and I've been terribly disappointed each time. I think it's because they don't use the best ingredients in their pies. In my time, I've...
Vigo V.
9/12/2024
Order was prepared incorrectly. Underside was soft and floppy. Very greasy. Go to a local pizzeria and steer clear of this chain.
Sara D.
7/30/2024
I walked in on Sunday night to grab a couple of slices and the two kids behind the counter were clearly overwhelmed. No one even acknowledged me for a solid 10 minutes. But I didn't want to take...
Peter B.
2/24/2024
We are so happy to find this place!! best pizza on Long Island hands down! AND run by awesome folks. Love places and people like this!
See a problem?
