David L.
7/15/2024
Best pizza I've had in a long time. Plenty of cheese sauce pepperoni just delicious. I will definitely be back there.
Otis & Reds Pizza
Closed
(9)
Photos
85 Main St
Phelps, NY 14532
Otis & Reds Pizza is a cozy pizzeria nestled in Phelps, NY, offering a variety of freshly made pizzas and other Italian dishes.
With a casual and inviting atmosphere, this eatery provides a convenient spot for locals and visitors to enjoy a satisfying meal.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.59 reviews
Matt D.
5/31/2024
In town and had to stop by. I am so glad we did. I was in the mood from some good wings and boy did this place deliver. These wings are life changing.
Steve S.
8/2/2023
Brand new pizza joint in Phelps. I just had a slice of pepperoni for lunch and it was delicious. They sport a thin New York style crust. Service ran smoothly for a new place that was pretty busy...
Ken D.
4/23/2024
Easy access, good pizza and the workers were very friendly there I would recommend checking this place out
Theresa L.
5/17/2025
probably the worst Cobb salad I've ever eaten or I should say tried to eat. chefs need to look up what actually goes in a normal Cobb salad. onions, peppers, banana peppers, etc. do not belong in...
See a problem?
