Nina E.
10/23/2025
We came on a Sunday to watch the Eagles game and we got there early to get a table. We ordered the cheesesteak spring rolls, the smash burger, and the cheesesteak. Everything was so good and the...
Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew
$$
Closed
(82)
Photos
66 Madison Ave
New York, NY 10016
Authentic cheesesteaks. Specialty cheesesteaks. Signature roast pork and chicken cutlet sandwiches with homemade broccoli rabe and Cooper sharp american. Bread shipped in from Philly and baked in-house every hour. Killer wings, salads, and fries. Craft beer on tap. Craftier cocktails. Televisions. Sports. A Sports Bar. Do we have your attention yet? Welcome to Olde City Cheesesteaks & Brew. Philly native and Olde City founder Evan Stein has been serving up cheesesteaks in NYC since 2005 with his original concept Shorty’s. Evan has moved on to launch this truly unique brand. Each item on the menu is delicious. The beer selection is carefully curated with local breweries from PA and NY. The creative cocktails are unexpectedly serious and always served without pretension. Olde City has something for everyone. The Olde City team will always make you feel like it's your City, too. #LoveOldeCity
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.082 reviews
Joshua R.
6/1/2025
I used to love this spot back when it was Shorty's--it was one of the few places in the city where you could get a truly authentic Philly cheesesteak. Even after it was rebranded as Olde City...
Cherrilyn B.
10/4/2025
Accidentally stumbled upon this Philly bar after work. The food was really good... happy hour was solid. Service was fantastic and fast. They were very nice and checked in on us often. Must visit...
Deanna P.
1/5/2025
I was craving a good philly cheesesteak, and upon doing some research found Olde city and it ranked among the best in the city. Placed an order for pickup for a regular philly with black pepper...
James S.
5/16/2025
Food: 3.3 Service: 3.2 Ambiance: 3.5 Value: 3 I traveled in to Manhattan from Brooklyn on a Friday at 11am specifically to get a cheesesteak. Fedoroff's is great but pricey, and I remembered Olde...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.