Old Mill

Open

(22)

Call

Website

Photos

[6152 - 6180] Depot St

Alfred Station, NY 14803

+1 (607) 587-9060

http://www.onedepotstreet.com

The Old Mill Inn is a charming American pub and eatery located in Alfred Station, NY. Housed within the historic structure of a former grain mill, this quintessential small town establishment has become a beloved gathering spot for both locals and visitors. Under new management, The Old Mill Inn offers an expanded menu featuring classic American cuisine and a variety of traditional favorites, inviting guests to experience the warm and welcoming atmosphere of this re-imagined pub.

Nestled in the heart of Alfred Station, The Old Mill Inn is a testament to the town's rich history and community spirit. With its rustic charm and comfortable ambiance, this establishment has evolved into a go-to destination for those seeking a taste of authentic American fare. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch or a hearty dinner, The Old Mill Inn promises a delightful dining experience that captures the essence of small town hospitality.

Generated from the website

Reviews

3.522 reviews

Vicki D.

6/22/2025

Had to stop in to see how they fixed it up. Great cold beer and wings. A must stop when I visit Alfred. I remember it from years ago. Nice, cozy spot.

Read more on Yelp

Eric C.

10/4/2025

I would have given 5 stars. Food was great! Had pb&j wings and they were amazing! But staff seemed confused and lost about who was waiting on what tables.

Read more on Yelp

Katie S.

10/20/2025

Easily the worst place I've ever eaten at. Avoid the Mac and cheese it's just noodles with dried up cheese. Waited over 3 hours to do apps dinner and desert. Over an hour between each meal. Spent...

Read more on Yelp

Ward J.

3/20/2025

I think I have just witnessed the worst thing I've ever seen at a restaurant. We were sitting there waiting for our food and this sweet elderly couple walks in the door out of the rain with big...

Read more on Yelp

Judy S.

11/26/2024

Nice interior upgrade, food is good and most of the times I was there the service was good but I think there is one young waitress who doesn't enjoy her job and the customer suffers.

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?

Bars and lounges, Eating places

Alex's College Spot

Alex's College Spot is a vibrant pizzeria located in Alfred, NY, perfect for students and locals alike. Known for its delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with fresh ingredients, this cozy eatery offers a welcoming atmosphere ideal for gathering with friends. With a variety of toppings and specialty pies, there's something to satisfy every palate. Don't forget to check out their daily specials and enjoy a slice in this energetic college town! Generated from this place's information

Bar (drinking places), Eating places, Grills (eating places)

Alexs College Spot

Alex's College Spot in Alfred, NY is a local establishment that offers a variety of services to college students, providing a convenient and comfortable space for studying, socializing, and relaxation. With a focus on creating a welcoming environment, Alex's College Spot aims to cater to the needs of students, offering amenities and resources that enhance their college experience.Generated from the website