Justine B.
10/27/2025
Calling all vegans or dairy-free folks to try out this spot!! They have some of the best vegan ice cream options on Long Island. They rotate their options, but they usually carry vegan vanilla...
Old Fashioned Ice Cream
$$
Closed
(90)
Photos
1025 Straight Path
West Babylon, NY 11704
Old Fashioned Ice Cream, located in West Babylon, NY, specializes in classic homemade ice cream crafted with traditional techniques. Established in 2010, the company aims to provide customers with a nostalgic ice cream experience reminiscent of simpler times.
Designed by Cryocon Multimedia, the brand reflects a deep commitment to quality and authenticity. Old Fashioned Ice Cream stands out for its dedication to serving delicious, time-honored flavors that appeal to ice cream lovers of all ages.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.590 reviews
Eddie W.
6/3/2025
Have been here well over 100 times in my life, and I've never been disappointed!! Best soft serve ever.
Christinee Raiola R.
8/26/2025
Best ice cream ever would highly recommend you should definitely check it out. Even if you don't live close, the drive is worth it.
Allison F.
12/1/2022
5+++ stars for Old Fashioned Ice Cream. The ice cream is so delicious and they have many flavors to pick from, some seasonal so if ya snooze ya lose! I'm partial to the chocolate flavors but...
Stephanie K.
11/16/2022
Alright, not the quaintest location to pack the kids up & go for ice cream BUT.....it certainly is Old Fashioned & good! We stop here for their sundae cups to bring to parties & their ice cream...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.