Lisa H.
6/15/2025
I'm shocked at how good this place is. Truly "odd" because of their amazing selection of UNIQUE flavors. I got the miso peanut butter and blackberry cheesecake biscuit. Both were amazing. - Good...
OddFellows Ice Cream
$
Closed
(24)
Photos
141 8th Ave
New York, NY 10011
OddFellows Ice Cream is a small-batch ice cream company based in New York City, known for their compulsively creative flavors and unique twists on classic favorites. Since their establishment in 2013, they have crafted over 500 unconventional and delicious ice cream flavors, making them a go-to destination for ice cream enthusiasts looking for something out of the ordinary.
With scoop shops in various locations across New York, Florida, Massachusetts, and Pennsylvania, as well as an international presence in South Korea, OddFellows Ice Cream offers a delightful and adventurous ice cream experience that is sure to satisfy any sweet tooth.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.024 reviews
Cole D.
9/17/2025
Fun place to try. Very nice service who was chatty and kind. Very generous taste testers. I got the cookie and mint and also the chocolate PB cheesecake. The cookies and mint was MINT. It was so...
Debbie S.
8/8/2025
Excellent! Not too sweet and nice and creamy. Loved the brooklyn blackout and banana Banoffee
Ryan C.
4/24/2025
Hits the spot! They always have a few vegan options. They do let you try flavors and there's some tables inside.
Carina H.
12/11/2024
I've passed by OddFellows a few times before but didn't realize it was an ice cream shop. When I searched this place up, I saw the variety of unique flavors and had to go back to try it out. I...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.