Kai S.
7/30/2025
I went to Nostalgia once for my friend who was performing there. It's really cute! I didn't have food or drinks, so I can't tell you how the service was. But the bartenders are very friendly! My...
Nostalgia
$$
Closed
(14)
Photos
380 N Wantagh Ave
Bethpage, NY 11714
Nostalgia, located in Bethpage, NY, is a unique venue that invites guests to relive the vibrant culture of the 90s through a variety of events, including live music, comedy shows, and themed brunches. Offering a playful atmosphere, it also features classic video games and a diverse menu of themed food and drinks, including signature cocktails inspired by iconic 90's pop culture.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.514 reviews
Lara-Celeste S.
8/1/2025
The bartenders are super friendly; the bar is super fun and the music is amazing. Also the pretzels are great!!!
Tiffany O.
10/9/2023
Awesome experience at Nostalgia. Came for a trivia night. Service from Marco the bartender/trivia host was impeccable. The decor bought me back to my youth with the movies, shows, toys and games...
Erin P.
4/6/2025
I don't know what happened to this place but seems like they don't care to put in effort to the aesthetic. The decor looks very thrown together. Like a messy kids room. The sponge bob theme looks...
Tiffany P.
3/30/2025
Overhyped dive bar. Disgusting food. Wouldn't recommend their special event experiences, they're a rip off.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.