Tom W.
8/29/2025
I've been going to Nicky's on a regular basis since 2017. When I went a few weeks ago, I saw an entire new staff, and was told that the owners were "on vacation". Went again recently and was told...
Nicky's Pizza & Deli
$
Open
(51)
Photos
22 Lafayette Ave
Suffern, NY 10901
Nicky's Pizza & Deli is a popular eatery located in Montebello, NY, offering a delectable selection of pizzas and deli sandwiches. With a focus on quality ingredients and exceptional flavors, Nicky's is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
Whether you're craving a classic cheese pizza or a hearty Italian sub, Nicky's Pizza & Deli delivers mouthwatering options that are sure to satisfy any appetite. With a commitment to excellent service and a cozy atmosphere, it's no wonder why Nicky's is a beloved dining destination in Suffern, New York.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
2.551 reviews
Sean S.
8/1/2025
40 minute wait for 2 pizzas and a salad. They didn't know what we ordered after 40 minutes. They still didn't have it made. The pizza came out looking like something a preschooler would have made....
Jacqueline A.
11/3/2024
Ordered some food right after long days work. Pizza had a nice crust, crispy and light.Toppings were fresh.The spinach calzone was jam packed with and the sauce had justennoguh acid to break...
Tom F.
7/24/2025
Zero stars. Absolutely pathetic. Canned spaghetti sauce, chicken cutlet dry and same quality as fast food. NO Mozzarella cheese for a chicken parm dinner. NONE!! They raised the price for the...
Aneesha M.
8/5/2024
I'm not a fan of Nickys Pizza. I've tried the cheese and pepperoni pizzas probably 20 times over the past three years due to events and it's never been something I like or enjoy eatung. I don't...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.