Nichole K.
7/11/2025
We happened to stumble upon Nick's Tomato Pie after visiting the MOST to check out the new Nature Photography exhibit and what a fantastic surprise it turned out to be! We came by on a Thursday...
Nick's Tomato Pie
$
Closed
(66)
Photos
109 Walton St
Syracuse, NY 13202
Nick's Tomato Pie is a cozy eatery in Syracuse, NY that specializes in serving traditional Italian-style tomato pies.
With a focus on quality ingredients and authentic flavors, Nick's Tomato Pie offers a casual dining experience for those seeking classic comfort food.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.566 reviewsDawn ..
7/27/2025
Better staff!! I'm a recent widow that was taking to a customer when I witnessed the staff became upset and picked a customer up by him neck as through him out of the store. Unbelievably...
Phil H.
10/11/2024
Conveniently located in the heart of downtown, this pizza place is only populated after 10pm and for good reason: the pizza is mediocre and staff bullies guests. Probably will not be coming back...
Laura W.
7/14/2024
It's a slice shop where you can get a pie and it's open late. Usually for places open late the quality isn't that great, especially when surrounded by bars, but with that all in mind, I don't...
Laura R.
12/18/2024
Happened to stumble upon this place. The employees were absolutely terrific and welcoming. They have a lot of seating in the attached room. Pizza slices were nice and crunchy. Enjoyed the tomato...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.