Rebecca C.
10/31/2025
Fantastic local pizzeria. Enjoyed a large half pepperoni pizza, delicious garlic knots and bread sticks. Staff were so friendly and helpful as we were travelling through the area and had called in...
New York Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(31)
Photos
1 W Main St
Marathon, NY 13803
New York Pizzeria in Marathon, NY is a local eatery that offers delicious pizza and Italian cuisine.
With a focus on quality ingredients and authentic flavors, this pizzeria is a go-to spot for locals and visitors looking for a taste of New York-style pizza in Marathon.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.031 reviewsCharles B.
4/26/2025
Stopped in for quick lunch. Very clean huge slices of pizza. Taste was great definitely coming back
Michelle C.
4/16/2025
I really liked their chicken parm, side salad,garlic bread,and boneless wings.That was about it unfortunately their Stromboli was under cooked and their pizza was dry not a lot of sauce. The staff...
Barbara E.
8/20/2024
New owners food is wonderful. It's now Mamma Maria. The place is clean and the food is wonderful. Tuesday -Saturday 11- 8
Colette H.
4/23/2019
So yummy! And convenient to get to. Stopped here for some cheese slices because I was starving. It was so good. Speedy service and delicious pizza. I definitely recommend this place!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.