Adrien V.
4/7/2025
I ordered around 11:08, told them I'm in a huge hurry for work, they said no worries I arrived at 11:22 in a hurry, to literally find my food ready and packed for me to go I was so stunned by how...
New York Avenue Pizza
Closed
(12)
Photos
1727 New York Ave
Huntington Station, NY 11746
New York Avenue Pizza is a local pizzeria in Huntington Station, NY, offering a variety of pizza options and other Italian dishes.
With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional recipes, New York Avenue Pizza provides a casual dining experience for customers looking for a taste of authentic New York-style pizza.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.012 reviewsKarla R.
7/28/2025
I went to this pizza place and they stole $40 dollars from my gift card. They don't want to pay me back and they just keep denying it. DO NOT USE YOUR CARD THERE OR THEY WILL STEAL FROM...
Lori R.
2/15/2025
Fast service, good food. My family loves the sweet sauce, so glad they kept it when they changed hands.
Andrew P.
7/19/2024
I loved Guiseppe's Pizza, It was not the sweet sauce for me, but the sesame crust. When it closed, I was sad. The recent revitalization of the spot was exciting, so when they opened, I had to...
Sam S.
8/24/2024
Although I do miss Giuseppes ( Joe) and the pizzeria, I have to say New York Ave., Pizza has basically carried the torch and has kept things the same as they were. The sweet pizza is still there...
See a problem?
