Ken L.
4/21/2025
Great company to do business with. Amazing selections and first rate packaging of their mailed stamps. Everything you might need and a real person to speak to when needed.
Mystic Stamp
$$$
Closed
(38)
Photos
9700 Mill St
Camden, NY 13316
Mystic Stamp Company is a postage stamp dealer serving stamp collectors throughout the United States. The company offers stamp expertise and training programs to ensure proper identification and condition of its customer-received stamps. Mystic can provide information on all types of stamps including definitive, commemorative, airmail, postage due, special delivery, parcel post, official and revenue stamps. Customers can order stamps with the company s online U.S. stamp catalog. Scott numbers are used in Mystic s U.S. Stamp Catalog and Hard to Find Stamps Catalog. Many rare and unusual U.S. postage stamps are illustrated in its catalog, including the rarest United States stamp, the 1867 one-cent Z Grill. Mystic was founded in 1923 and is located in Camden, N.Y.
Reviews
2.038 reviews
Dan H.
5/12/2025
This company is a scam. I asked for a FREE catalog and received a number of stamps and they are asking for $29.39. The stamps are not worth anywhere close to that amount furthermore I own most...
R G.
7/11/2025
I received a flyer it stated for $5 you would receive the stamps pictured ($100 value). I called asked if I would receive stamps pictured was told yes. I didn't receive said stamps. Was very...
Elizabeth S.
12/22/2024
I inherited a stamp collection a few years ago and have been slowly organizing them, adding to the collection, last year after a lot of back and forth with Mystic Stamp, I packaged up my...
Wes D.
6/3/2025
Both myself and my father, now deceased, have had accounts with Mystic for decades. They are on the high side of prices (because they are a retailer), but they 100% back everything they sell and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.