Myrtle Ave. Bagels

$
Closed
yelp logo

(99)

Photos

410 Myrtle Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11205

Reviews

yelp logo
3.599 reviews
Photo of Jose O.
Jose O.
7/28/2025

Absolutely obsessed! The blueberry cream cheese was unexpectedly amazing--so flavorful and fresh. This place has officially become my new go-to spot in Brooklyn. Can't wait to come back!

Photo of Colin J.
Colin J.
8/23/2025

Excellent service excellent bagel. Must try cucumber dill spread on an everything bagel. The everything bagel chips and ask for the cream cheese spreads on the side for a little snack.

Photo of Brandon P.
Brandon P.
7/17/2025

Myrtle Bagel is a solid bagel shop in Fort Greene. The shop is standard with a few tables and counter to order. My first visit, I bought a few bagels to go and were impressed by how big each bagel...

Michael C.
8/23/2025

Great bagel -- the cucumber dill cream cheese is so unique and so delicious. I'm sold on this place. New owners, great branding. You can't go wrong. Plus the vibe is great.

Photo of Brandon T.
Brandon T.
12/30/2024

I only stop in here to grab bagels to go, so can't speak to any of the other items, but the bagels are awesome. The price is definitely affordable, and the staff hustle to get everything done. No...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkBrooklynMyrtle Ave. Bagels