My Cousin's

$
Closed
yelp logo

(78)

Call
Website

Photos

954 Route 6
Mahopac, NY 10541
+1 (845) 648-2600
http://mycousinsmahopac.com
My Cousin's was founded in 2021 by David Gallo. David grew up in Yorktown Heights and started his restaurant career washing dishes. He eventually became a cook before making his way to the front of the house, waiting tables, bartending, managing, and eventually ownership. My Cousin's is his second restaurant venture. David helped open The Chophouse Grille in Mahopac in 2012, and eventually sold his share in 2015. After David left the Chophouse, he was introduced to fine dining working for Lidia & Joe Bastianich in Manhattan, at the world-renowned Del Posto waiting tables. It was here David gained a better appreciation for the artistry and scientific precision of running a Michelin star restaurant. While David plans on bringing that level of detail and professionalism to My Cousin's, the atmosphere will be more laid back and comfortable.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
5.078 reviews
Photo of Gillian J.
Gillian J.
6/1/2025

Five stars. One of the few places I have reviewed where I have given a full five-star review. Restaurant itself is beautiful. Great lighting, ambiance and bar. Casual but in a fancy way. I'm glad...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Pat H.
Pat H.
8/12/2025

Food was excellent as was service. I had eaten here when it opened several years ago and for some reason forgotten about it. I am so glad to have rediscovered My Cousin's. I will be back soon!

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Mary E.
Mary E.
4/11/2025

Wow. This place surprised me. The inside is fancy and pretty, but also casual. The service was great and attentive! THE FOOD! It was so yummy, and I will be back again.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Joe Z.
Joe Z.
6/26/2024

Anthony, is our waiter? and he has a great attitude and he's awesome at his job. So my fiancé wanted a burger, but with no bun, they made it so beautiful believe it or not. Take a look at the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Tanya P.
Tanya P.
8/6/2025

The best place in Mahopac for Brunch and Dinner! Dave is just simply the best! He's such a wonderful person and makes sure your dining experience is memorable! Food and Drinks are amazing! Highly...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Trattoria Sei
Italian restaurant, Bars and lounges, Eating places

Trattoria Sei

Located in the heart of Mahopac, NY, Trattoria Sei blends authentic Italian tradition with fresh, seasonal creativity. Enjoy handmade pasta, crispy Chicken Milanese, our signature dry-aged SEI Burger, and housemade desserts—paired with curated wines and crafted cocktails. Join us for our prix fixe lunch with a salad course, perfect for a midday getaway or business meeting. Whether it’s a romantic date night, family celebration, private event, or casual pizza night, we deliver generous portions, warm hospitality, and the best Italian in Putnam County. Available for dine-in, takeout, DoorDash delivery, and off-premise catering. Book your table today and savor the tradition—with a twist.
Red Mills Pub
Bars and lounges, Bar (drinking places), Eating places

Red Mills Pub

18
•
$$
"I love this spot. My wife is from the area and we've found it hard to find a casual sports bar with good food. This is the best. The wings are absolutely fantastic as is the other bar food. Both..."
photo of Adam N.
Holy Smoke
Eating places, Bars and lounges, Barbecue restaurant

Holy Smoke

266
•
$$
"Delicious food. Easy to get a table. Attendant very nice and polite. I really recommend"
United States›New York›Mahopac›My Cousin's

Partial Data by Foursquare.