Mustang Sally's American Bar & Grill

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(10)

Call

Photos

70 Old Ithaca Rd
Horseheads, NY 14845

Reviews

yelp logo
2.510 reviews
Kevin O.
2/10/2017

Went with my wife for a Friday fish fry. Absolutely delicious. Love the coleslaw, smoked beans and mac and cheese as well. Horseheads IPA on tap topped off this meal. Service was great and the...

Photo of Sally V.
Sally V.
5/29/2017

We came here more to find out what the place was It was not a dining experience. The bartender was by herself, the chicken fingers were basically Tyson frozen chicken fingers My hubby ordered a...

Photo of Mike G.
Mike G.
3/9/2017

Went there with my wife to see a live band. I was told by employees that the food got better so I decided to give it a third chance. We sat there right at a table for 45 minutes and not one person...

Photo of M P.
M P.
3/5/2017

As a bar, it's great. As a restaurant, not so much. Great stop after Horseheads Brewing Co. I like the big glasses of wine and good IPA choices. Very cold beer and wine. I like the look and feel...

Photo of Julie C.
Julie C.
10/2/2015

Restaurant and parking lot have been beautifully redone. Sadly, the food, not so much. We ordered beef nachos for the table. Waitress put in for the pulled pork nachos. Ok no problem. However,...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkHorseheadsMustang Sally's American Bar & Grill

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.