Monty C.
1/12/2023
New to the area and stopped in for the first time yesterday. This place is fantastic. Friendly people, great drinks and pint. Nice short bar menu including the wings that were tremendous....
Mustang Sally's
$$
Open
(11)
Photos
186 Howells Rd Slp Town
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Mustang Sallys is a popular establishment located in Bay Shore, NY, offering a vibrant and lively atmosphere for locals and visitors alike.
With its energetic ambiance and diverse range of entertainment options, Mustang Sallys is a go-to destination for those seeking a memorable night out in the area.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.511 reviews
Thea W.
4/23/2025
A few things. 1, if you're not a regular- don't go here. they make you feel unwelcome & look at you like you have 4 heads. 2, unless you're over 80, don't go here because it's cash only and...
Tom M.
1/5/2025
Ordered a tray of buffalo wings on the fly. Done in no time. Wings came out crispy and tasty. Buffalo sauce spot on with a great mix with of heat and tang. Great blue cheese with plenty of flavor...
Paul C.
10/20/2022
Owner Enda is a friendly, super, knowledgeable, hospitable person from Monaghan in the north of the Emerald Isle
Diana L.
11/9/2019
My favorite place! The wings are fantastic and Lisa makes the BEST dirty martini in the world!!!!
See a problem?
