Brandon G.
8/14/2025
We are new to the neighborhood so we are on the hunt for our new pizza spot closeby. We tried out Muscarella's the other night and it was great. We ordered delivery while we were unpacking boxes...
Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY
Closed
(16)
Photos
470 Aurora St
Lancaster, NY 14086
Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY is a local eatery in Lancaster, NY that specializes in serving a variety of pizzas and Italian dishes.
With a cozy atmosphere and friendly service, customers can enjoy a casual dining experience at Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY.
Generated from their business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.016 reviewsJohn D.
8/8/2025
Absolutely delicious pizza! I've come in a few times and have had great help from one of the weekend managers here, I think his name is Lucas. He was very knowledgeable about the whole business...
Shannon R.
12/30/2022
My husband and I did a Lancaster/Depew pizza tasting review on YouTube a few years ago (we were bored and heck, we like pizza). We wish Muscarellas would've been in the area back then because now...
Lauren S.
12/20/2022
Small little place next door to the express Tops. Pizza is decent, it's not the best nor the worst in the area. If you like burnt (charbroiled) pepperoni, it might be a great place for you....
Michele V.
4/13/2024
I ordered from them last week and I was very happy with the food. I ordered a half pizza with pepperoni and single order of wings medium. Everything was delicious!
See a problem?
