Mylie P.
9/17/2025
what a great place. seriously if you're looking for somewhere to go, check it out you won't regret it. VERY CLEAN! SPOTLESS!! The workers were so kind and will make your whole day! Cookies and...
Mr. Pot Pie
$$
Closed
(31)
Photos
140 Grey St
East Aurora, NY 14052
Mr. Pot Pie, located in East Aurora, NY, is renowned for its delicious pot pies and frozen entrees, offering a taste of comfort food that has delighted customers since 1976. Originally serving grocers, hotels, airlines, and coffee shops, the bakery expanded its reach in 2010 to bring high-quality baked goods directly to the people of Clarence, Williamsville, and surrounding areas in Western New York.
In addition to their famous pot pies, Mr. Pot Pie features a variety of baked goods, including fresh-baked breads, pastries, and specialty cakes, all made with the finest ingredients. The bakery's commitment to quality and service has made it a beloved staple in the local community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.531 reviews
Lucy Y.
10/15/2024
We walked in today - around 11am on a Tuesday & bought a frozen mini Guiness pot pie & a frozen mini chicken pot pie to take home to bake & a small chili to eat there. The chili was surprisingly...
Myra C.
4/1/2024
The chilli amazing! The choices from different types of soup, definitely ask if it's dairy-free because there wasn't no signs. The staff were very helpful, we bought fresh sesame bread and a...
Paige T.
4/2/2024
So glad I stopped in. I love pies and Mr Pot Pie was delicious! I purchased a berry pie as well as a chicken pot pie. The berry pie had a perfect blend of sweet and tart. The crust was...
Susan Jaworski J.
5/25/2024
Good pot pies with different from the usual varieties. Personal favorite is the chicken curry. Yum!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.