Christine R.
8/9/2025
First, our server, Jen, was a real pro. She helped steer our selections, kept our drinks full & was super prompt. Second, this is the cleanest dive bar that I've ever stepped in. I mean seriously...
Mitchell's Tavern
$
Closed
(54)
Photos
734 Sheridan Dr
Tonawanda, NY 14150
The history of Mitchell's dates back to the 1940's. James Mitchell purchased the property for the Mitchell family returning home from World War II. The original building was located by what is now the Dunlop Tire Factory. The building was moved to the current location, operated as a Deli before transforming into a Tavern. In the early 1970's, my Great Uncle Peter purchased the Tavern from the Mitchell Family. Peter owned the Tavern up to the late 1980's when my parents purchased the Tavern from him. For over forty-five years and as the third generation, my family has served WNY with the best we have to offer. While glancing through the bar area, it's easy to become lost among the sports memorabilia, selection of beer and spirits! Mitchell's has gained a reputation for quality products, a friendly environment and family-like customer service.
Reviews
4.054 reviews
'Keith P.
8/29/2025
The food was great. The service was pleasant with great attitudes and attentiveness to service But DO NOT pay with a debit card as their credit card system double charges at times And we are...
Jen E.
5/17/2025
Unassuming bar and restaurant. We sat in the dining area that had a pool table, tables, and booths. Not very busy. Smelled like disinfectant, so guessing that means they clean well. Service was...
Vicky B.
6/2/2024
Mitchell's is a friendly neighborhood bar and restaurant with a few craft and domestic beers on tap, a full bar, and delicious food. It's true that they have the best Beef on Weck! It's juicy and...
Greg O.
8/23/2024
The beef on weck was amazing. Did the special that comes with 5 wings too and the wings were really good. Service and beer selection is also good.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.