Jasmine A.
10/5/2025
Always notice how people are in & out of this place. So I finally gave it a try one early Sunday morning after doing laundry. I called my order in & the lady on the phone was very friendly &...
Miracle Bagels
$
Closed
(43)
Photos
372 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor, NY 12553
Miracle Bagels in New Windsor prides itself on crafting bagels the old-fashioned way, using a traditional boiling method to ensure freshness daily.
With a commitment to quality, their bagels are made from the finest ingredients, resulting in a delicious and authentic taste that sets them apart.
Generated from their website's infomation
Reviews
3.543 reviews
Vivian A.
11/25/2024
Ordered a BLT on a plain bagel and really enjoyed the crispness of the bacon. Since the bagels were thick, I felt like it needed more lettuce or extra tomato to help with the thickness of the...
John T.
7/21/2025
Great service and the bagels are the best! Would definitely recommend. Im in there every morning
Mike D.
12/13/2024
I think this might be 1 egg....maybe. I also have to explain what a scrambled egg is. If I didn't show them a picture they would make an omelet. Pretty disappointing from a solid bagel spot. I'd...
Jeremy B.
10/10/2024
These are the best bagels to take home, slice and freeze - they come out perfect when toasted - taste fresh even after being frozen for a week! Great service too, very nice folks. Wish they...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.