Wendy R.
7/24/2025
My sister, my husband and I went there for the first time. We all thought the pizza was pretty terrific! The service was fast as well!
Middle Island Pizza
$$
Open
(81)
Photos
586 Middle Country Rd
Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island Pizza is a local pizza delivery service located in Middle Island, NY. They offer convenient online ordering and delivery services, making it easy for customers to enjoy their delicious pizzas from the comfort of their own homes.
With a user-friendly website created and managed by their team, Middle Island Pizza provides a seamless online experience for customers to add their favorite pizzas to their order and join their email list for exclusive offers and updates.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
2.581 reviewsEileen A.
7/27/2025
Chicken piccata and chicken francese dinners were horrible. Tasted as though the cook literally pored a bottle of lemon juice over both with abandonment. Requested angel hair pasta, was given...
Paul S.
7/28/2025
Ordered a pizza and dinners from them through their website using Slice. Food didn't show up as scheduled. I called the restaurant and got no help at all. Turned out the food was delivered to...
Jhon C.
4/7/2025
Food was great, the service was amazing, the workers are very nice and the feel of the place is very comfortable.
Mike S.
4/27/2025
I called Thursday night for an eggplant hero. I told them NO parm and not to toast the bread. I arrived to pick it up and checked it. It was smothered in mozzarella cheese. They took it back and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.