Joel S.
8/25/2025
This is one of my favorite kinds of restaurants- a small, old school pizzeria/Italian restaurant that punches above its weight. Situated in a strip mall, it's easy to miss. The decor is classic...
Michelangelo of Speonk
$
Closed
(39)
Photos
295 Montauk Hwy
Eastport, NY 11941
The chef, Joe Guardascione, has over 35 years of cooking experience. He has worked for three well known Italian restaurants on Long Island in Suffolk County, NY. We are a family owned business located in the Village Square Shopping Center on 295 Montauk Highway in Speonk, NY 11972. Michelangelo of Speonk is under new ownership as of January 7th, 2015
Also at this address
Reviews
4.039 reviews
Tracy K.
8/13/2025
There are a few Michelangelo's all in the same area! This one is in the strip center with Pearl, and Brewology. Located just west of the Hamptons its a perfect place to regain sanity when dining...
Natalie M.
6/1/2025
Food tasty and plentiful. Food served hot. Service excellent. Servers polite and friendly. Small dining room, rolls good but I prefer the crusty Italian bread.
Dana I.
11/9/2024
Great food, caring staff , and a nice ambience. Wednesday night is chicken night . Thursday night's seafood night . Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, is past the night. So much to choose from.
Joseph T.
2/27/2025
My Name is Joe Torres, this restaurant is my go to restaurant in the westhampton Eastport area, Anthony and the rest of the staff are great and the food is good. I love their Sicilian pizza with...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.