Sammy K.
12/18/2023
An amazing bar! They don't serve food. That means dogs are welcome! ONLY WELL BEHAVED DOGS! Bartender was nice. Went through the list of tequila options for me and got me setup in no time....
McGarrets
$
Closed
(21)
Photos
946 Elmwood Ave
Buffalo, NY 14222
McGarrets is a cozy restaurant in Buffalo, NY that offers a diverse menu of comfort food classics and modern twists on American cuisine.
With a relaxed atmosphere and friendly service, McGarrets is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike to enjoy a casual dining experience.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
4.021 reviewsA F.
5/21/2025
One of two bars on Elmwood that will not accept vertical IDs. Totally fine but you should not toss the ID back to us and tell us to get out when we ask if we can still stay to play darts. All you...
Owen R.
4/29/2022
One of the best bars in America! ;) What do I know.... Terrific set up, no frills, no fuss. Some amazing bartenders. Pool table and darts. Buffalo has some amazing bars.
Alex L.
11/14/2017
As someone who doesn't drink alchy, McGarrets had absolutely nothing to offer for me except as a place to hang out and celebrate a friend but they still get a good rating for friendly bartenders...
Zach E.
2/3/2023
McGarrets is a great place. It's my favorite. The owner has a dog. There's table games.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.