Elizabeth S.
9/30/2025
Got the large pizza and 12 wings for dinner. 8.5/10 for sure on the pizza. Great cook, sweet sauce, good cheese and toppings. they sprinkle a little oregano on top which you may like if you're not...
Mattina's Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(112)
Photos
6040 Sheridan Dr
Buffalo, NY 14221
Mattina's Pizzeria, established in 1992, is a family-owned establishment renowned for its authentic Buffalo-style pizza, wings, chicken fingers, and made-to-order subs. With two convenient locations in Williamsville and Tonawanda, they pride themselves on accommodating food orders of any size and providing both pick-up and delivery options.
Committed to quality and customer satisfaction, Mattina's Pizzeria has earned a reputation as one of the best pizzerias in Buffalo. Their dedication to traditional recipes and fresh ingredients ensures a delicious dining experience for all patrons.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.0112 reviews
Luke P.
8/25/2025
Great tasting pizza. Competitive pricing and great service. Order was ready on time. Martina's is now my go to place for pizza
W. Brien B.
11/10/2025
This is a Solid choice for pizza and wings ..... it's on my short list of best Pizza in Amherst
Sara K.
1/17/2025
I mostly only stop in for a slice or 2 (depends on my hunger - usually 1 slice is enough) and blue cheese (it is January 2025 and for reference it's about $9 for 2 slices and a Cains blue cheese -...
Rick P.
12/31/2024
Sloppy greasy pizza. Stopped in for the $9 lunch special where you get two slices and a coke. The pizza is very soggy, doughy and greasy. I understand this style of pizza but it's poorly executed....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.