Erick D.
5/24/2018
The Best Pizza and Homemade meatball Subb evvveeerrrrrrrrrr! I'm greeted as soon as i walk in the door with super fast service; I Highly recommend the GodFather Pizza!
Matteo's Pizza
Permanently closed
(52)
Photos
2350 Nesconset Hwy
Stony Brook, NY 11790
Also at this address
Reviews
3.552 reviews
Kathleen S.
10/12/2018
We stopped in here after eating dinner at a nearby establishment. We were reeled In by the 'gelato' signs. There were easily twenty flavor options available, and you had the option of a cone or...
Erica L.
5/13/2018
This is really a 2.5 rating rounded to a 3. The pizza is not cooked enough. For having such a big oven imported here from Italy why is it so soggy? We had a 16" Margherita Napoletana and a 16"...
Saumya B.
1/28/2019
It's such a damn shame that management changed here. 081 Pizza was amazing, high-quality Italian pizza. Since it became Matteo's the menu has completely changed to crappy, average pizza. Ordered a...
Symone F.
5/12/2018
I ordered a larger pepperoni and meatball pizza. It was not greasy and tasted clean. The only thing it needed was a little more salt.
See a problem?
