Romana Y.
6/28/2024
Excellent toy store and location... just off the park. Arrived here after the MET, and found a vast selection of toys and a great selection of books. Jellycat bunnies - of many sizes and colors...
Mary Arnold Toys
$$
Closed
(35)
Photos
1178 Lexington Ave
New York, NY 10028
Mary Arnold Toys is a beloved toy store located on Lexington Avenue in New York City. With a wide selection of toys, customers can shop by category, brand, or age to find the perfect toy for any child.
As a family-owned business, Mary Arnold Toys is dedicated to providing a safe shopping experience for their customers. They require masks, encourage social distancing, and provide hand sanitizer for all visitors.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.535 reviews
Royce L.
8/29/2022
There aren't too many toy stores left so this store is a little bit of a diamond in the rough. It's mostly for younger kids but my niece who's 11 years old loves to come here still. Decent sized...
victoria p.
7/21/2023
NYC longest continually running toy store, Mary Arnold Toys is a gem and I'm so glad we found it on our recent trip. They have toys and accessories for all ages, from newborn through tween. Our...
Victoria A.
10/5/2024
This excellent store features toys that are great, and the staff are awesome. There is a vast selection of toys. I once bought a horse on a pole that plays music. It might have been Rear Admiral....
925k S.
2/6/2025
The staff were amazing, and incredibly funny there were many toys to pick from and my friends and I left the store with a smile because of the incredible staff there. Totally Recommend.
See a problem?
