Tiffany H.
6/20/2025
Perfect for a hot day, service is friendly. Love the selections. My favorite flavor is Straciateli n dark chocolate So good. There's a line but it moves fast
Mammamia Gelato
Closed
(6)
Photos
1729 2nd Ave
New York, NY 10128
Mammamia Gelato, established in 1911, offers a wide range of innovative and classic gelato flavors characterized by artisanal quality. Among their offerings are four internationally awarded flavors, including Variegato Amarena and Pistacchio Crunch, showcasing their commitment to excellence in gelato production.
In addition to gelato, Mammamia Gelato features a selection of semifreddi and various dessert pairings, all prepared quickly and on-site for customer enjoyment. The café also provides a diverse coffee menu, ensuring a delightful experience for gelato and coffee lovers alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.06 reviews
Queen R.
10/7/2025
So I just paid a little over $20 for two cups of ice cream -- two scoops for me, two for my guy. Except when I say "two scoops," I mean something closer to half a spoonful and a whisper of a...
Tiffany T.
10/8/2025
This is.... such a disappointing spot. Genuinely bad. It is even gelato??? Tastes very strongly of artificial flavors (I had vanilla and lemon).
Anthony P.
1/3/2025
UES gets another gelato place - all in all, not bad. I got strawberry and chocolate and they were solid, though I think NYC has tough gelato competition and there are so many great spots. I think...
Evan N.
12/4/2024
While they had a very large variety of flavors it just really fell short for me. Everything was just extremely artificial tasting to me, especially their swirls of caramel and pistachio. With a...
See a problem?
