Sandy S.
10/11/2025
Michelle is by far the best waitress alwa ys attentive and always goes out of her way for us
Mama Theresa's Pizza Restaurant
$
Closed
(73)
Photos
374 Windsor Hwy
New Windsor, NY 12553
Mama Theresa's Pizzeria Italian Eatery, located in New Windsor, NY, is a family-owned establishment celebrating over 10 years of serving the Hudson Valley. With roots in Brooklyn, the restaurant offers a tradition of homemade culinary creations, utilizing only the freshest and finest ingredients.
Specializing in traditional Italian dishes and imported specialty items, Mama Theresa's aims to evoke the warmth of an old-fashioned Sunday dinner. Their contemporary specials add an enticing twist to classic fare, making dining and catering experiences memorable for families and corporate events alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.073 reviews
Daniel A.
2/19/2025
Been here now 6/7 times. Did is delicious, pizza is solid, flavors are on point, and service quality is next to perfect. Ambiance is cool, chill, smaller, pizza shop quality.
Christian S.
10/25/2025
Great thin slice pizza. Specialty slices are great as well, and their cheesesteaks are great.
Lee O.
11/25/2024
The Pizza was most definitely BK style....I ordered the broccolini it was so delicious & the rice balls with sauce with mozzarella so divine. Excellent food.
Jose B.
9/4/2025
This the third time in a row I ordered and they messed up. Today I ordered 20 garlic wings which cost me 30.00 I get home and they are freaking Plain wings. Last time I go hear
See a problem?
