Brianna T.
8/2/2025
I stop here sometimes after work when I feel like I've had a rough day and want to reward myself with a sweet treat. There are so many options, so I can reward myself with something taste like 20...
Make My Cake
$
Open
(43)
Photos
409 W 125th St
New York, NY 10027
Make My Cake is a renowned bakery in New York City, specializing in creating delightful cakes that evoke cherished memories.
With two convenient locations in Harlem, Make My Cake offers a wide range of delectable treats, including custom wedding cakes, and is committed to providing exceptional service to its community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.043 reviews
Jeff M.
4/3/2025
Make My Cake 409 W. 125th. St. New York, NY 10027 Key Lime Cheesecake This bakery certainly made my day when they served my cake. I definitely got the best of both worlds with a combination of...
Bernice N.
6/7/2025
Service was amazing. I stopped here to get my girls some cupcakes because I was ordering some chicken next door. I walked in to a pleasant young lady with a warm bright smile on her face to ask me...
Elisabeth W.
9/6/2025
Gift card didn't work. I purchased an online gift card for my friend and wanted to support a local business. When she went to the store, the staff member was unable to redeem the code
Sandy F.
6/2/2025
I am such a dessert girl and I remembered this wonderful bakery. My friend was visiting from the UK and we were exploring Harlem. It was a beautiful day and decided on some sweet treats. First of...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.