Crystal P.
9/15/2025
Adorable place. Again super long line but it moved fast. Loved our ice cream. Perfect end to the night.
Main Street Sweets
$
Open
(173)
Photos
35 Main St
Tarrytown, NY 10591
Main Street Sweets, located in Tarrytown, NY, is a delightful ice cream shop owned by sisters Corie and Marlaina and their mother, Kathy Buonanno. The shop boasts a charming mural of Main Street and offers homemade ice cream, pies, cookies, and brownies.
This family-run business is known for its private "make your own sundae" parties, which are popular among kids. With a cozy atmosphere and delicious homemade treats, Main Street Sweets is a must-visit for those with a sweet tooth in Tarrytown.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0173 reviews
Angela L.
10/27/2025
We wanted a milkshake. Looking around we found this little place with handmade ice cream. When I walked over it was super crowded with all the people waiting for the Halloween parade. Someone...
Vincent W.
11/5/2025
I was pleasantly surprised how tasty the treats were. Specialty sweet ship with a full staff of teenagers working a local business so it could be slow due to suburban nature and experience....
Christopher Y.
10/18/2025
a nice local dessert spot in sleepy hallow! Kinda gave old school vibes which is definitely cool. Ended up getting the apple cider with a glazed apple cider donut ($5). Price point was there & the...
Kathleen L.
7/8/2025
It was a warm Sunday evening and this was perfect end to a girls beauty day . I've been trying to come but either there is a line or I'm rushing I was happy to be able to try their delicious...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.