Cyrus A.
7/6/2025
I've been coming to Magic Fountain since I was a kid, and for good reason! They have delicious ice cream from a rotating menu of flavors that has so many interesting concoctions. On my most...
Magic Fountain
$
Closed
(283)
Photos
9825 Main Rd
Mattituck, NY 11952
Magic Fountain is a beloved ice cream parlor in Mattituck, NY, known for its diverse selection of homemade flavors.
From classic favorites like strawberry and pistachio to unique offerings such as chocolate chili and Guinness, Magic Fountain caters to a wide range of tastes.
Generated from their available business information
Also at this address
Reviews
4.5283 reviews
Glenn K.
9/15/2025
This is one of the best homemade ice cream shops on the Island, yes it's on the East End in Mattituck but so definitely worth the trip. They have over 50 flavors and priced right for your...
Allen A.
8/30/2024
I really enjoyed my gluten free coffee ice cream. Yes - it is a bit touristy Yes - the prices are a bit high Yes - the line can get quite long But - everyone seems to be ok with that and just...
Loretta P.
7/31/2025
Visiting with friends and we checked hours on line to be sure they were open. Drove 30 min to get there in the evening. Guess what - closed on Tuesday and Wednesday. Wish that was clearly stated...
AJ L.
7/15/2023
This place is THE BEST ice cream I have EVER had, and that's no understatement. This place has been part of the Mattituck community for many years and for good reason. They have well over 50...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.