Madison Fare

Open
yelp logo

(51)

Photos

1225 Madison Ave
New York, NY 10128

Madison Fare is a cozy eatery in the heart of New York City, offering a diverse menu of culinary delights.

With a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, Madison Fare provides a welcoming atmosphere for patrons to enjoy a satisfying dining experience.

Generated from their business information

Reviews

yelp logo
4.051 reviews
Photo of Jasmine P.
Jasmine P.
7/16/2025

As you can tell by the photo, we couldn't wait to dig into our frozen yogurt. I love pistachio, kataifi, and froyo, so naturally this dessert checked every box for me. We were visiting New York...

Photo of Harry X.
Harry X.
7/19/2025

The froyo is really good (especially if you like a tart frozen yogurt), with excellent texture. I'd give it a 4.5/5 on its own. But $16 for a small serving of froyo with a small amount of...

Photo of Yong K.
Yong K.
7/14/2025

followed the hype train for the pistachio froyo... Price is pretty darn high $16 but... def worth a try. The froyo itself was really good. so creamy and right balance of tart and sweet. The...

Photo of Laura Jean O.
Laura Jean O.
9/3/2025

Worth the hype. What a sweet guy that works here, genuinely nice and full of energy. A boat load of school kids piled in for afternoon snacks! They have raspberry topping and the pistachio. Simple...

Photo of Vanessa T.
Vanessa T.
8/31/2025

Salted Caramel Crunch I believe is what it was called? Not sure why this is so expensive honestly because the station the guy was working from was not clean and messy. The store seemed like a...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkNew YorkMadison Fare