Mike R.
4/16/2025
Hadn't tried "Made in New York Pizza" before, perhaps turned off by its Captain Obvious, cheesy (no pun intended) name and non-descript decor, however decided to give it a try for a basic cheese...
Made In New York Pizza
Closed
(7)
Photos
2563 Broadway
New York, NY 10025
Made In New York Pizza is a vibrant eatery located in the heart of New York NY offering an authentic New York-style pizza experience. With a menu featuring classic slices specialty pies and fresh ingredients it caters to both locals and tourists alike. The casual atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a quick meal or a relaxed dining experience with friends and family.
Generated from this place's information
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.57 reviews
Alexis C.
8/14/2025
A really solid pizza place that's open late. Came here on the way home from watching a musical since it was one of the few places still open so I thought I'd check it out. It's really clean inside...
Giacomo C.
5/5/2025
I'm a fan of the other locations and this one makes no difference. I'm particularly keen on the squared pizzas, both the Grandma and the Sicilian. The Upside Down is my favorite of the Sicilian....
George A.
5/30/2025
New clean pizza place in the area. I decided to give it a try and the eggplant hit the spot! Friendly service. Will return!
Burnard B.
8/8/2025
Pizza was okay; mid level. Service was bad and not welcoming. The price is without tax! Typically most pizzerias include the tax into the cash price but not here. The location itself looks very...
See a problem?
