Matt M.
5/30/2025
I was in New York City for less than a day, but maiden New York was one of my son's favorite pizza stops when he and his friend did a pizza tour of the city. So I knew that I couldn't come back...
Made In New York Pizza
$
Closed
(625)
Photos
421 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10024
Made In New York Pizza is a renowned pizza shop in New York City, offering award-winning pizza made from fresh, natural ingredients and high-quality cheeses. With their unique dough made using famous NYC water, they have perfected the art of creating delicious and authentic New York-style pizza.
At Made In New York Pizza, they not only take pride in serving the best pizza in NYC but also strive to create a welcoming and fun atmosphere for all. Whether you choose to dine in or order online, their menu offers a wide variety of flavors and toppings to satisfy every pizza lover's cravings.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.5625 reviews
Julia S.
8/8/2025
Quick service; tasty pizza, what more can you ask for? Do be aware that not all their pizza options are listed on their menu!
Johnathan N.
7/27/2025
As much as I dislike writing 1-star reviews, it's important to share my experience so others can make an informed choice. This location is very small, with only four tables available for customers...
Sarah Kate K.
11/9/2025
Stopped here for a slice of pizza. It was tasty, service was fast. It's walking distance from the American Museum of Natural History. There's indoor and outside seating. The garlic knots are great!
Alyssa S.
10/25/2025
Wanted some classic NY pizza after our visit to the Natural History Museum and this place was a quick walk away. The staff inside were welcoming and service was very quick. The place was clean and...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.