Lost Toys and Comics

Permanently closed
yelp logo

(1)

Call

Photos

451 Route 25A Unit 10
Miller Place, NY 11764
+1 (631) 743-9443

Lost Toys and Comics, located in Miller Place, NY, is a specialty toy store offering a wide selection of books, games, crafts, puzzles, and educational toys.

Carrying popular brands like Brueder, Hot Wheels, Play Mobile, and Melissa and Doug, Lost Toys and Comics caters to children of all ages with a diverse range of products.

Generated from their available business information

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.01 reviews
Photo of Tim N.
Tim N.
9/7/2025

A great local Comic and card shop that has a ton of really fun, nostalgic toys, cards, and comic books from the late 70s, 80s, 90s, in 2000s. It's only open on the weekends, but the service is...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Derrick’s Sports Cards

Derrick’s Sports Cards

6
"My sons favorite place to go to support his card hobby. Knowledgeable staff. Quality cards. Good prices. Nice people. What more could you ask for?"
Grand Slam Collectibles
Services, nec, nec

Grand Slam Collectibles

4
"Terrific "LCS" - local card shop. They carry lots of singles and packs. They also carry a full suite of supplies at reasonable prices. The folks behind the counter are very cordial and..."
photo of Michael M.
Chosen One Collectible Toys

Chosen One Collectible Toys

8
•
$$$
"All things considered, Chosen One is a fantastic toy and collectible store. The store is clean, well stocked, and the employees are very friendly and helpful. In addition to just being generally..."
photo of James H.
United States›New York›Miller Place›Lost Toys and Comics