Thomas M.
9/20/2025
Place is well maintained with lots of seating options and a big, broad menu. The staff were incredibly friendly. Most importantly, however, the breakfast box - a whole feast for $13 - is a...
Long Island Bagel Cafe
$
Closed
(184)
Photos
2310 Nesconset Hwy
Stony Brook, NY 11790
Long Island Bagel Cafe-Stony Brook is a popular bagel store in Stony Brook, NY, known for its authentic, rolled, old-fashioned New York bagels that are boiled and baked to perfection every day.
With eight convenient locations across Long Island and Westchester, Long Island Bagel Cafe offers a wide variety of menu options, including daily specials, catering services, and even a BBQ menu. Their commitment to quality and traditional recipes ensures that customers will have a memorable bagel experience.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.0184 reviews
Emily O.
9/20/2025
Disorganized and understaffed with long wait times and not great service. Bagels are decent but the sandwiches are very expensive for what you get. We placed an online order for a couple of...
Kay E.
6/4/2025
Always busy. Always great. It's a fast paced ordering system so be ready with your order. The fact that they are busy is a good sign that people keep coming back.
Pat A.
1/7/2025
Bagels & Egg sandwiches vary by day. Sometimes they're 5/5 & others are 2/5. Staff are friendly and the interior is clean. I'll return
Marco Uniti D.
1/12/2025
I haven't really found a worst bagel store than this one. Long Island has some of the best bagel places around and stores abound...sometimes 3 to 4 in the same town. We ordered egg sandwiches...
See a problem?
