Sujal B.
8/2/2025
Bottom line--great pizza for n the neighborhood. (For locals, same place, different name). Had garden pizza. Three words: ah-ma-zing! Nice service--prompt and friendly. Like old architecture...
Limelight Original Famous Coal Fire Pizzeria
$$
Closed
(866)
Photos
656 6th Ave
New York, NY 10010
Grimaldi's Coal Brick Oven Pizzeria is a renowned institution in the world of pizza, celebrated for its history of coal-fired brick oven cooking, which dates back to the first pizzeria in America in 1905. Customers rave about the unique smoky flavor and crispy crust that are characteristic of this traditional cooking method, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Located in various spots, including Manhattan and Brooklyn, Grimaldi's offers simple yet deliciously crafted pizzas at reasonable prices, complemented by cheap beer options nearby. With its commitment to preserving the art of coal-fired pizza, Grimaldi's continues to attract both locals and tourists seeking an authentic dining experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5866 reviews
Johanna B.
10/4/2024
Limelight Coal Brick Oven Pizza was a first time experience for me. It was previously Grimaldis Pizza and going back even farther in time, it was a club (known as Limelight) in the 80s and 90s....
Chelsea M.
8/23/2025
Pizza here has gotten ridiculously expensive. Large pie with pepperoni ($4) and sausage ($5) came up to $46 and change. Not how it used to be under Grimaldi's name. Good pizza but in NYC that's...
Dan B.
12/23/2023
If you're looking for good pizza, look no further. Their pizza is outstanding! The ingredients are fresh, the tomato sauce is delicious - not overly sour nor overly sweet, the cheese is...
MaDonna W.
11/15/2023
I just had to step inside this pizzeria/old church. Amazing space . Through the restaurant they have bar and lounge. This just blew my mind as it was once a church. We were there just as they...
See a problem?
