La Gelateria di Eataly

Open
yelp logo

(4)

Call

Photos

23 W 23rd St
New York, NY 10010

Find related places

Reviews

yelp logo
5.04 reviews
Photo of Ritvi S.
Ritvi S.
11/8/2025

One of the best gelato places in the city. We tried 4 different flavors and could barely decide until we tried pistachio and it immediately won us over. Service was great, live music was playing...

Photo of Seby I.
Seby I.
10/23/2025

Always a pleasure to come here to have sublime gelatos and to greet Chef Patricia. Todays's flavor is California Blossom with orange and almonds. Subtle and flavorful.

Photo of Randall M.
Randall M.
10/9/2025

Well? I'm not as enthused about Gelateria as the previous reviewers. I stopped in and sampled two flavors. The Coffee Gelato was very good, but it was too strong. I went with Pistacchio instead....

Photo of Katelyn W.
Katelyn W.
7/15/2025

The service was amazing! I came in craving affogato and they had the option to get a double shot of espresso with 2 scoops of ice cream. It was delicious and the cashier recommended the cappuccino...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesNew YorkNew YorkLa Gelateria di Eataly