Kismet Inn

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(75)

Photos

1 Oak St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

The Kismet Inn Restaurant and Marina, located in Fire Island, New York, has been a cherished family establishment for 84 years.

With a focus on family values, the inn offers a unique dining experience and marina services for visitors to enjoy.

Generated from their website's infomation

Reviews

yelp logo
2.575 reviews
Photo of Justin M.
Justin M.
8/1/2025

What a great 'island' dive bar feel The staff is awesome , Taryn is an incredible bartender !! Larry , thank you ;) Best Bloody Mary I've had in a long time !! Can't wait to come back!!!

Scot F.
10/4/2025

Worst service ever. Three weeks in a row waited hours no service. We left along with many others. How do you not know or be prepared. The dive closes for parties and could care less about their...

Photo of Steven G.
Steven G.
8/2/2025

Suffice to say, missed the mark on everything from service to food. Forgot appetizer, missing utensils, no olives, lemons, limes , straw on my Bloody Mary? not attentive in the least to get...

Denise M.
10/5/2025

I was so looking forward to a nice lunch after walking over from field 5 Robert Moses. Food was awful. Baked clams were burnt, fish sandwich was over cooked and the lobster roll was awful. It was...

Photo of Jessica R.
Jessica R.
7/12/2023

I love it here. I come here every time with my dad and his girlfriend. It's great when you come off the boat/ferry. There is a lot of tacky fish at the front of the bar but it's not overbearing....

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.