Kismet Inn

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(73)

Photos

1 Oak St
Bay Shore, NY 11706

The Kismet Inn Restaurant and Marina, located in Fire Island, New York, has been a cherished family establishment for 84 years.

With a focus on family values, the inn offers a unique dining experience and marina services for visitors to enjoy.

Generated from their website's infomation

Reviews

yelp logo
3.073 reviews
Photo of Justin M.
Justin M.
8/1/2025

What a great 'island' dive bar feel The staff is awesome , Taryn is an incredible bartender !! Larry , thank you ;) Best Bloody Mary I've had in a long time !! Can't wait to come back!!!

Photo of Steven G.
Steven G.
8/2/2025

Suffice to say, missed the mark on everything from service to food. Forgot appetizer, missing utensils, no olives, lemons, limes , straw on my Bloody Mary? not attentive in the least to get...

Bob M.
7/11/2025

Stopped in to grab a bite to eat and a couple of cool ones at the bar after a day of fishing. The three stars are for the ice cold beer, but the baked clams were lukewarm full of breadcrumbs and...

Photo of Jessica R.
Jessica R.
7/12/2023

I love it here. I come here every time with my dad and his girlfriend. It's great when you come off the boat/ferry. There is a lot of tacky fish at the front of the bar but it's not overbearing....

Photo of Cathy D.
Cathy D.
8/13/2024

food was not good. too much salad dressing on caesar salad $8.95 and add 3 shrimp for $14.75 and your cost for a lousy small salad is $23.70. Mussels were overcooked and shrimp bisque soup had...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.