Heather B.
8/1/2025
Sweet little shop. Super nice people working here. Shares a door opening to a bigger bar. Not sure if customers can sit in there but it's an option. The baked goods look awesome!
Kismet Coffee - Bay Shore
Closed
(25)
Photos
17 E Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
Kismet Coffee is a specialty coffee company that originated as a humble stand on Fire Island during the summer of 2022. With a commitment to great vibes and quality brews, they now operate three locations, including Bay Shore and Ocean Beach.
The brand offers a variety of coffee products and merchandise, showcasing their passion for coffee and customer service. Kismet Coffee is always on the lookout for individuals who share their enthusiasm for the coffee experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.525 reviews
Amanda L.
8/15/2025
I was really excited to try Kismet Coffee because I have heard a lot about it! The inside is small but cute. I like how it connects to the winery next door. The barista was very friendly and...
Orena W.
7/23/2025
This place is so cute. I love their logo, and the red themed decor. I just wish it was bigger there were only 2 tables there. However, they are moving to a new location in September! So excited...
Amy E.
9/16/2024
Wanted to like this place but it ended up being mediocre at best. My friend and I ordered an iced coffee, a vanilla sweet cream cold brew, and a breakfast burrito to split. My coffee was good but...
Maria C.
1/29/2025
Very cute teeeny spot located inside FI Vines. They always have the best music playing too. Their coffee is very good! Nutty taste to their espresso/lattes. I always get with oat milk and today...
See a problem?
